The Catcher in the Rye discussion guide:

A few conversation starters.

Use this discussion guide to inspire in-depth thinking, and jump-start a conversation about J. D. Salinger’s controversial novel, The Catcher in the Rye. There’s plenty here to set your mental wheels in motion.

  1. Do you find the characters likable, or at least sympathetic? Why or why not? And does it diminish the novel’s message if you don’t find them likable or sympathetic? Why, or why not?
  2. Holden Caulfield’s go-to insult is to refer to people as “phony.” What does he mean when he calls someone a “phony”?
  3. Why do you think Salinger chose New York City as the setting for his novel? Is it simply because there’s more mischief for Holden Caulfield to get into? Or, does this setting suggest that The Catcher in the Rye is about something more than teenage angst and coming of age?
  4. As Phoebe Caulfield tells us, “the catcher in the rye” is a reference to the Robert Burns poem  Comin’ Thro the Rye.  What does the title signify, especially since Holden gets Burns’ poem wrong?
  5. Phoebe Caulfield is, of course, Holden’s sister. But what purpose does this character serve in the novel? What does she signify, and why?
  6. Discuss Holden’s observations about the carousel’s gold ring at the end of the novel. What is the significance of the ring?
  7. Do you, like many, read The Catcher in the Rye as a  study of teenage angst, of coming to terms with adulthood? Or do you see it as a larger commentary on American society? And does it have to be one or the other?  Either way, do you think The Catcher in the Rye is still relevant? And, needless to say…why, or why not?

And, be sure to send us your newly-discovered insights
in the Comments section at the bottom of
The Catcher in the Rye: A Twentieth-Century Jeremiad.

Page Capper copy

#post-war social commentary      #banned books     #Puritan          #published 1950s

Join Our Community sign up block

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

Sign up for our newsletter.
And get a “Discover Everything a Book
Has to Offer” packet. They’re both free!

Sign up for our newsletter.
And stay up to date
with new arrivals at
This Book is
It’s free!

A library of “unlocked”
books, tools for enhanced
reading, and essays about the
benefits of the Humanities.
Dig in!

Reading can be a skill, or it can be
an art that develops independent
thinking and judgment.
Here are a few tools
to aid you on that journey.

Sometimes that adage doesn’t
mean what our Google-driven
world thinks it means.
Check out a few
unplugged aphorisms here.

As Mary Poppins taught us,
words can be fun. Remember
Well, that’s just a start.
Click here to have a gander.

You’ll get a heads-up about new posts. And, we’ll keep you up to date about the regular additions we make to all the other good stuff that lives on This Book is

Get Free Banned Books:

Free banned books at
Get free banned books at Internet Archive
Get free banned books at Public Domain Review
Get free banned books at
Unite Against book banning here